Katherine Bailey on Books  
Book Reviews, Literary Essays


Reviews: Current Books Watergate by Thomas Mallon

Once again Thomas Mallon captures the tone of an era, giving us an historical novel replete with credible characters, moral insights, and humorous moments. His previous novels include Henry and Clara and Dewey Defeats Truman.

In the 1970s, a time before the miracle of electronic data-storage, the Watergate scandal generated an amazing amount of paper documentation. Thomas Mallon has infused this monumental archive with freshness and immediacy to portray the drama – and dark comedy – of Nixon’s final years in office. Watergate, a novel that deftly combines political scope with intimate characterization, is filled with humor, thanks in part to the chicaneries of Alice Roosevelt Longworth and Martha Mitchell.

Some of the plot unfolds through the perspective of Elliot Richardson who in the space of six months held three cabinet posts – Health, Education and Welfare; Defense; and Justice. A prominent character, he comes across as a pretentious self-promoter. (“I haven’t told a lie since I was 13!”)

More likable is the lesser-known Fred Larue, a Mississippian who had worked for John Mitchell, Nixon’s Attorney General. Through LaRue we learn about the “third-rate burglary” in which five men broke into the DNC offices. According to LaRue their mission was to find evidence that Castro’s regime had been funneling money to the Democratic Party.

One of the five burglars was Howard Hunt, a seasoned CIA operative who deliberately left behind evidence of his participation in the crime, thus establishing a starting point for the Washington police force in its investigation. Almost immediately the cover–up becomes more important than the break-in.

At the time of the burglary Pat Nixon was in Moscow on a goodwill mission. The depiction of Pat is certainly on of the novel’s strong features. She is intelligent, friendly, poised and often inscrutable. Shaped by an era in which wives were programmed to defer to their mates, she is, above all, loyal to Dick. She even restricts her smoking to private, “off-stage,” moments.

There are no surprises in Mallon’s characterization of Nixon. He remains the same relentlessly ambitious and self-destructive man that we remember from his years in and out of power. His epic hubris and persistent unhappiness thread authentically through the book.

In time it becomes abundantly clear that the President will be impeached. In a memorable moment when an aide suggests that he resign, Nixon flashes “that madly dissociative smile,” and pompously states: “That would be the cowardly thing to do.”

Yet Mallon is an author who sympathizes with his characters. Early in the book he notes Nixon’s genuine affection for John Mitchell: “What [Nixon] wanted most was to know that Mitchell was not responsible, and that these investigations…wouldn’t claim the friend to whom he owed so much.”

Watergate offers no explanations as to why Nixon failed to “come clean” with the facts of the burglary from the very beginning. It offers, in fact, no answers – except perhaps that statecraft, because it relies on human nature, is often messy.